Which Personality Types Most Enjoy Being a Parent? Based on Data
Having a child is one of the biggest decisions anyone can ever make. It’s a lifelong commitment that requires immense patience and dedication. It can also bring a great deal of joy and fulfillment. For some, the rewards of parenthood outweigh the challenges. For others, the sacrifices feel more significant.
Having a child is one of the biggest decisions anyone can ever make. It’s a lifelong commitment that requires immense patience and dedication. It can also bring a great deal of joy and fulfillment. For some, the rewards of parenthood outweigh the challenges. For others, the sacrifices feel more significant.
Different aspects of parenthood can appeal to different personality types. Some may enjoy the nurturing and caregiving parts, while others may thrive in the role of a teacher or mentor. In this post, we explore which personality types most enjoy being a parent and why. The data used for the ranking is based on a Truity survey of 2,689 mothers and 818 fathers about parental satisfaction. The ESTP and ISTP personality types were omitted due to the small sample size. Here is a summary of the findings.
Average parental satisfaction score by personality type
Ranking the 16 personalities by parental satisfaction
Before we get started, it’s important to note that personality type is just one factor in a person’s overall experience as a parent. There are many other factors that can influence how much a person enjoys being a parent, such as personal values, support systems, and financial stability.
This ranking is about satisfaction rather than skill. All personality types have the potential to be incredible parents, and all personality types can face challenges in this realm. This ranking isn’t meant to be definitive or prescriptive, but rather a general overview of how certain personality types may approach and experience parenthood.
Another important point to note is that these results are based on people who decided to have children. There are, of course, many people who choose not to have children, and that is the right decision for them. There are also people who want to have children but are unable to do so for various reasons. The survey focused solely on those who are parents and their level of satisfaction in that role. So it’s a self-selected sample that isn’t representative of all individuals of a certain personality type.
1. ESFJ (parental satisfaction score = 26.41)
ESFJs reported the highest level of parental satisfaction. This may come as no surprise, as ESFJs are known for being warm and nurturing individuals who excel at taking care of others. In fact, that’s a defining characteristic of this personality type. They take great pride in creating a stable and harmonious home environment for their family. Being a parent allows ESFJs to fully embrace their natural caregiving abilities, and their organizational skills come in handy when managing the day-to-day tasks of parenthood.
2. ENFJ (parental satisfaction score = 26.10)
Like ESFJs, ENFJs are highly empathetic and dedicated people who get a lot of satisfaction from helping others. They are natural teachers and leaders, and they bring these qualities to their role as parents. ENFJs are often exceptionally talented at understanding their children’s needs and emotions, making them nurturing and supportive parents. Their selfless nature means that they don’t find it too difficult to prioritize their children’s needs, and they get a great deal of joy in helping their children grow and develop. One of the most common challenges for ENFJs as parents is remembering to take care of their own well-being, too.
3. ESTJ (parental satisfaction score = 25.81)
ESTJs are known for being loyal, responsible, and practical individuals. These qualities serve them well as parents, as they are able to create a structured and disciplined environment for their children. ESTJs take pride in teaching their children important values, such as instilling a strong work ethic. They also excel at sticking to routines and schedules, which can help children feel more secure and stable. However, ESTJs may need to be mindful of being too rigid in their parenting approach, and they can sometimes be closed-minded if they have children who want to live an unconventional life.
4. ENFP (parental satisfaction score = 25.67)
ENFPs are free-spirited and creative people who thrive on new experiences and opportunities. As parents, they bring this sense of adventure and open-mindedness to their children’s lives. They often enjoy the imaginative and playful aspects of parenthood, and they greatly value meaningful connections. As such, they are often deeply invested in their emotional connection with their children. However, ENFPs may struggle with the more mundane aspects of parenting, such as managing household tasks and enforcing rules. They can also find it difficult to balance their independence with their parental responsibilities.
5. ENTJ (parental satisfaction score = 26.61)
Compared to the other Thinker personality types, ENTJs reported high levels of parental satisfaction. This may be due to their ability to approach parenting with a logical and strategic mindset. ENTJs are natural problem-solvers, which comes in handy when managing the challenges of parenthood. Organizing and delegating tasks comes easily to them, and they are often able to create a well-structured and efficient household. However, ENTJs can struggle with the unpredictability and lack of control that comes with being a parent.
6. ISFJ (parental satisfaction score = 25.59)
You might expect ISFJs to rank higher on this list since they are known for their nurturing nature. On the one hand, they are one of the few personality types who are able to balance the emotional and practical aspects of parenting. Keeping on top of household tasks and schedules comes naturally to them, and they are often great at making sure their children feel loved and supported. However, ISFJs have a tendency to worry, which can lead to them being anxious and stressed as parents. This can detract from their overall level of satisfaction.
7. INFJ (parental satisfaction score = 25.59)
INFJs are known for their deep understanding of others and their compassion. As parents, they are often highly supportive and engaged, which can make their children feel seen and heard. INFJs also have a strong desire to help others grow and develop, which can translate well into the role of a parent. However, their perfectionist tendencies can make them overly critical of themselves as parents, and similar to ISFJ’s, they may struggle with anxiety around their children’s well-being.
8. ESFP (parental satisfaction score = 25.56)
ESFPs are warm and fun-loving individuals who enjoy living in the moment. As parents, they bring a sense of joy and spontaneity to their children’s lives. They are great at fostering creativity and helping their children explore new interests. Think jam-packed weekends full of fun activities. However, long-term planning and consistency, which is important for creating a sense of stability, doesn’t always come naturally to them. ESFPs can’t stand feeling tied down, and they have a free-spirited nature. As such, they can find it challenging to manage the responsibility and commitment that comes with being a parent.
9. ISFP (parental satisfaction score = 24.97)
Like ESFPs, ISFPs are free-spirited and they bring a sense of creativity to their children’s lives. They are individualistic and value personal freedom, which can make them understanding and non-judgmental parents. Encouraging their children to be themselves and express their individuality often comes naturally to ISFPs. They are the kind of parents who enjoy showing their children the beauty of the world, particularly when it comes to nature. However, ISFPs can struggle with enforcing rules and structure. They can also be sensitive and take things personally, which can make them feel hurt or rejected if their children don’t appreciate their efforts as parents.
10. INFP (parental satisfaction score = 24.95)
INFPs are sensitive and empathetic individuals who can excel when it comes to the emotional side of parenting. They are accepting and non-judgmental, which can make their children feel safe and supported. Their creativity and imagination make them great at thinking up with fun activities and experiences for their children. However, they may struggle with the more practical aspects of parenting, such as sticking to a mealtime routine or doing school runs. They also value their freedom and need alone time to recharge, so parenting can sometimes feel overwhelming for them.
11. INTJ (parental satisfaction score = 24.62)
INTJs are great at thinking about the long-term and planning ahead, which can be beneficial in their role as a parent. They are good at setting boundaries and enforcing rules, which can provide structure and stability for their children. However, their highly logical approach to life can make certain aspects of parenting difficult, such as dealing with children’s seemingly irrational emotions and unpredictable behaviors. As one of the most independent and self-reliant personality types, INTJs may also struggle with the constant demands on their time and attention as a parent.
12. ENTP (parental satisfaction score = 24.54)
ENTPs rank the lowest out of all the extroverts on this list, and by quite a way. This may come as a surprise considering their natural curiosity and playfulness. They tend to excel at the more creative aspects of parenting and they are easily able to adapt to the different phases of their children’s development. However, they may find it hard to deal with the more hands-on tasks like changing diapers and making meals. Essentially, they crave novelty and variety, which can be at odds with the repetitive nature of parenting. In addition, they have a tendency to become easily bored and may find it challenging to maintain consistent interest in their parental duties. Intellectual stimulation is important to ENTPs, and this can be difficult to find in the day-to-day responsibilities of parenthood.
13. ISTJ (parental satisfaction score = 24.34)
As arguably the most traditional and rule-abiding personality type, you might expect ISTJs to rank higher on the list of parental satisfaction. On the one hand, their consistency, organizational skills and reliability enable them to create a stable environment for their children to thrive in. However, their tendency towards rigidity and adherence to tradition can make it difficult for them to adapt to changing situations. ISTJs often have a need to feel in control and they like to plan even the smallest details. But this isn’t always possible with children, who often bring a level of chaos and unpredictability. ISTJs can also find it hard if their children don’t conform to their expectations.
14. INTP (parental satisfaction score = 23.41)
INTPs have the lowest parental satisfaction score on the list, but that isn’t necessarily indicative of their parenting skills. While they are great at problem-solving and finding creative solutions to parenting challenges, they may struggle with the emotional aspect. INTPs tend to rely heavily on logic and rationality in decision-making. This can sometimes lead to a lack of understanding of their children’s emotions and behaviors. Additionally, INTPs strongly value their independence and need a lot of alone time, perhaps more than any other personality type. This can be challenging as a parent, where they may feel constantly needed and overwhelmed by the responsibility of caring for another human being.
General trends in personality types and parental satisfaction
There are also broader trends that are worth exploring. For starters, feeler types rank higher on the list, while thinker types rank lower. This is likely due to the fact that feelers have a natural inclination towards emotions and empathy, which can mean they are more comfortable understanding and dealing with their children’s feelings. Thinker types, on the other hand, may struggle with the seemingly irrational behaviors of children, but they can excel at staying calm and logical in challenging situations.
Overall, extroverted types rank higher on the list. This is no surprise seeing as parenting requires a lot of energy and social interaction, which extroverts thrive on. Introverts, on the other hand, may find it more draining to constantly engage with their children and keep up with the demands of parenting. That said, introverted types also have unique strengths as parents, such as creating a calm and peaceful environment for their children to grow up in.
Another trend is that judging types tend to report higher levels of parental satisfaction than perceiving types. This could be due to their natural inclination towards structure, organization and planning, which can make them more equipped for the rigorous demands of parenting. Having children requires a level of consistency and routine, something that judging types excel at. However, perceiving types can bring their adaptability and flexibility to parenting, which can be hugely beneficial in certain situations.
There isn’t a clear pattern when it comes to intuitive and sensing types. On the one hand, intuitives tend to think about the big picture, and this can make it easier for them to remember the significance of their role as a parent. When times get tough, they are better able to think see beyond immediate obstacles. On the other hand, sensing types are well-equipped to handle the more practical aspects of parenting, such as organizing schedules and keeping track of household tasks. They live in the real world and are better at dealing with the here and now.
Final thoughts on parental satisfaction and personality types
As we alluded to at the start, parental satisfaction can vary greatly depending on many factors, not just personality type. Parental satisfaction isn’t the same as being a “good parent” or having a healthy relationship with your children. In fact, more dutiful and conscientious parents may have lower satisfaction scores because they give up so much of themselves for their children. I’m just playing devil’s advocate here, but it’s food for thought.
One of the beautiful things about personality frameworks is that they can highlight specific strengths and challenges of different temperaments. For example, ENFPs may struggle with the more mundane tasks of parenting, but they excel at bringing joy and creativity to their children’s lives. ISTJs can bring stability and consistency, but they may need to work on being more flexible and open-minded.
At the end of the day, no one is perfect, and everyone has their own unique struggles and strengths as a parent. There are common archetypes of the “perfect parent,” but trying to fit these ideals can be exhausting. It’s much better to embrace your own unique approach to parenting. Yes, it’s necessary to give a lot, but you also need to take care of yourself and your own needs in order to be the best parent you can be. There isn’t one single “right” way to parent, and embracing your personality type can help you carve out your own unique path.
If you aren’t currently a parent and you’re wondering if having children is for you, we hope this has given you some points to consider. While your personality type isn’t the only factor in determining whether you should or shouldn’t have children, it can give you insights and points to reflect on.
Ultimately, being a parent is a deeply personal choice and one that requires serious consideration. Having a child is one of the biggest responsibilities anyone can take on, and it’s important to consider all aspects of yourself and your life before deciding whether to embark on that journey. If you don’t think that having children is for you, that’s completely okay. If you do decide to become a parent, remember to embrace your own unique approach and be gentle with yourself along the way.